Monday, December 1, 2008

Superficial Investing, Misunderstanding Under (and Over) Performance, and On Being an Optimistic Skeptic

Dan Richards (no relation) has a thought provoking (and short) article in The Global and Mail here that reminds us that things are never quite what they seem, in good times or in bad. He starts off:

Psychologists talk about the human propensity to gravitate towards evidence that supports existing biases. What that means, quite simply, is that in buoyant markets, investors are prone to believe outrageous claims by market bulls – think no further than “the world has changed forever” rhetoric and best selling books like “Dow Jones 36,000” and Harry Dent’s “The Great Boom Ahead” in the tech boom in 1999 and 2000.

In the same way, in negative markets such as we’re experiencing right now, investors tend to believe even the most gloomy assertions from “media gurus” and self appointed experts - a recent New York Times article headlined “Forecasters race to call the bottom to the market” discussed the competition among market pundits to come up with the most dire possible predictions. (It’s noteworthy that the same Harry Dent who wrote “The Great Boom Ahead” has just published “The Great Depression Ahead.”)
I encourage you to read the complete article (again, it's very short), for the analysis he does of several commonly touted facts about stock market returns. Anyhow, he ends like this:
None of this is intended to say that stocks will always be a safe or pleasant haven for investors. And despite the overwhelmingly positive returns that long term investors in U.S. stocks have seen across virtually every time frame, there is always the possibility that it could be different going forward. Just remember, though, the only guide we have going forward is what happened in the past. And in looking at the past, we need to look at all the facts – not just those selected by people looking to grab newspaper headlines.
One item I'd add to it: Statistics regarding under-performance AND over-performance touted are both misleading without qualifiers and rarely as meaningful to a given individual investor as they are lead to believe. I have several reasons for stating this and, at the risk of leaving things hanging and encouraging people to misunderstand me since this also touches upon other areas of investing which I've formed strong opinions about, here are some quick reasons:
  • Some investors invest in markets (namely those who invest solely in index funds). Other investors invest in companies (those who select & invest, on whatever basis they've determined makes sense for them). And, yes, I realize plenty of folks are essentially hybrids of these two types. These two types of investors have dramatically different strategies. In many cases the returns of the various indexes are irrelevant to investors in individual companies and, interestingly, the inverse is true as well (i.e. the returns of any given individual company are irrelevant to index investors).
  • Market investors who get in (and out) at different times have dramatically different results even against long-term (say, 20+ year) metrics. This is because even over the long-term, a very small number of days, weeks, or months can account for a large percentage of the overall returns calculated into the average. Unfortunately, the majority of individuals get bit by this one far more than is often believed due to human psychology and our inability to tell the difference between temporary losses of capital and permanent (often exasperated by not truly understanding what we're investing in too)
  • Indexes are NOT actually the market. Every index is a bit different and represent some portion of the market in different ways. The Dow Jones Industrial Average for example, says absolutely nothing about mid-size and smaller companies and, for that matter, anything about any companies other than the top thirty largest (and most widely dispersed ownership) public companies. Which companies actually fall into this category actually change from time to time (imagine that). The components of the index thus are dynamic over time. That throws a bit of a monkey wrench into the possibility of even holding onto the DJIA for a long period of time (the allusion that it's not changing if you own an index fund is only because you don't own the underlying securities directly). This is to say (almost) nothing about how the weighting of individual stocks (and their price changes) is done inconsistently between indexes (and also not necessarily representative of how an individual investor would view the same portfolio of stocks if held directly).
Those who I'll call Superficial Investors are generally universally and especially hard hit anytime things are not all hunky dory in the stock market. I use the term Superficial by way of attempting an explanation and not to be judgmental. Superficial Investors are not really speculating nor are they truly investing (I define investing as Ben Graham did: where upon thorough analysis, it promises safety of principal and a satisfactory return.)

Superficial Investors (SIs) are essentially the masses of folks that have (generally) modest sums of capital in the markets by way of retirement accounts, mutual funds, college savings funds, and the like. Many also have regular brokerage accounts and can toy with investing directly in individual companies that way as well.

It's no surprise that most folks with money in the market these days have no idea what to do. After all, they really didn't know what they were doing to begin with. They were only under an allusion (of self-deception, though not maliciously or even knowingly).

Warren Buffett said just after September 11, 2001 that you only find out who has been swimming naked when the tide goes out. There's a lot of truth to that and its a recurring theme throughout history in many areas other than investing (though it may manifest itself around the search for profits more so than any other).

The credit mess (loans related to real estate but other types as well) falls into this category as well. Though my impression is that more than a few folks did understand they were being foolish - and chose to look past it for short-term gain (now, for a bit of medium-term pain too, doh!). Presumably the majority of folks were simply misinformed and did not understand what was going on...while they were also trying to honestly "get ahead" and saw an opportunity. Something essentially all Americans seek, right?

Human psychology is great at fooling all of us much of the time. Especially when things are good. But the same happens when everything is bad too.

There in lies an optimistic tone. Rarely are things as good or as bad as the popular belief at any given point in time. And there are always opportunities to make money in the market. But they are not for everyone - and that's fine.

My conclusion: Know what your place is (as in decide what it's going to be deliberately and take action that is in harmony with that decision; I'm not saying accept what someone else simply says is "your place" or whatever other clique that phrase may conjure up). And be cautious who you allow to shape your actions -- especially in areas where you are not fully informed yourself.

More specifically, unless you have a solid knowledge of the facts yourself (as well as, perhaps, aspects of human psychology and especially your own), you will be unable to combat some of the distortions and temptations you will be exposed to. If at all possible, invest the time to ramp up your understanding of history and psychology to be a better resource to yourself. If you fail to do this, be careful who you allow you shape your actions, since you are trusting that they've done their homework (yeah, that includes me).

My wife once called me cynical but I had to correct her by saying "I'm not a cynic; I'm a skeptic". It's generally my default initial position. Further, I'm an optimist too. I really don't see a discrepancy between the two.

An ironic twist I suppose is that being a skeptic makes it easier to be confident since I can trust myself more. And that (along with some other things) keeps me pretty optimistic most of the time.

All of the above has ramifications far beyond investing in the stock market - and beyond the pursuit of money - and I hope that if you've read this far that I've been successful at conveying a bit of that sentiment.

-jr

P.S. If you're further interested in the topic of human psychology as it relates to investing, google "behavioral finance" and "behavioral economics". Again, despite its (apparent) ties to finance & economics it's really all about every day human behavior and even a cursory awareness of its implications would benefit you no matter what your area of expertise or aim in life.

Tuesday, November 4, 2008

The SLO School of Law

Nifty. Locally we have the University of San Luis Obispo School of Law. They offer a part-time weekend program. I had no idea.

Monday, October 6, 2008

How A Dishwasher May Determine Your Success

As I sit here writing this, listening to our new dishwasher shoot, splosh, and steam our dishes to cleanliness, I'm forced to contemplate why our dishes used to pile up at our old place -- despite our best intentions.

Previously our dish washing foo was less than stellar.

In the old place we didn't have a dishwasher machine -- other than our own hands. We'd go through periods of keeping up on the dishes. It usually persisted through the first few days (rarely weeks) of clean house euphoria that resulted from spending a day cleaning the entire house or kitchen. Then, we'd fall off the wagon and dishes would pile up. Rinse repeat. Same thing every time.

Our behavior never changed despite our interest in keeping the dishes from piling up.

It was pretty frustrating. Each time we'd discuss it and get up the courage again, telling ourselves we'd do better this time. Then we'd fail. It became pretty stressful in and of itself.

Stress is usually the result of missed expectations. And our expectations were pretty shot to hell the millionth time around.

Now, throughout all this, one of us might pop in and pound some dishes out in random bursts but there was no consistency. And, usually, this was out of frustration over our falling off of the wagon versus a genuine desire to keep things clean. In an ironic twist, this actually added to the frustration -- because it seemed to be a demonstration to ourselves that we could do it when we chose to. So what the heck was our problem?

There had to be something that we were missing. The solution couldn't be that easy (just choosing to do it).

Sure, we could say it was because we just "didn't have the time" but really that was just a convenient excuse.

Our productivity, or lack thereof, was really driven entirely by our mood. We liked the idea of having a clean house and no dishes piling up. But, somehow, we just weren't totally getting it. Why were we committed to the idea but not the action? And what else was really going on?

  • What mental hurdle does it take to turn an idea into an action?
  • How do you know when you are failing because of, in fact, time (or an unrealistic goal) versus when you are failing because you are approaching things the wrong way?
  • How do you determine the difference between persistence (often a good thing when aiming towards a goal or dream) versus banging your head against the wall?
  • How do you effectively develop new habits (or change old ones) when you are "focused" on achieving a million other things in your life as well?
  • How do you coordinate this process across a household of different family members all with different time, energy, and stress tolerances and responsibilities?
How indeed.

Well, in our case, we got a dishwasher. :-)

But, the (more useful) explanation is of course more than that.

Yes, perhaps there were other things we could have done to motivate ourselves, penalize ourselves, etc. Perhaps we were too undisciplined. But sometimes a completely different approach is what is actually most effectively. Especially when there's no downside to doing something completely different.

Just because we could have found a way to achieve our aim, doesn't make it the best approach. I had no big deep down desire to prove to myself (and especially not anyone else) that we were the manual labor dish washing motivation experts. In fact, I just wanted clean dishes -- I didn't care how we got 'em as long as it didn't take much time, energy, or money.

I even only half jokingly mentioned to my wife that maybe we ought to hire someone to come in and do the dishes (and a few other things while they were at it). That thought stayed in my mind for a month or two but we never did pursue it.

In any case, sometimes tweaking the goal makes sense. The idea of hiring somebody actually was closer to where we should have been thinking even if it didn't end up being our ultimate solution. In our case, we were too focused on the goal of "how do we get -- and keep -- ourselves in the habit of washing the dishes?". It sounds simple now, but a lot of solutions do -- in hindsight.

Sometimes we get so caught up in a solution that we've been attempting that we become convinced that we "can beat it". That's not an un-admirable attribute, but we have to remember it can work against us to. Awareness of this problem is probably the best means of sorting out those situations where it is occurring from the others where raw persistence really is what's needed.

How we frame our problems (or goals) makes a big difference in our approach to them. In my case, caught up in the daily tasks and lots of other goals and dreams, I routinely frame seemingly less important issues (such as keeping the dishes from piling up) the wrong way. Most likely because I don't put enough energy upfront in pondering them. I am continually dumbfounded by how easily I can solve a stressful problem that's been lingering by simply re-evaluating the entire premise.

Often I'm stressing not because something isn't done but because I'm not yet sure how I'm going to get there. Or, the goal isn't really all that clear to begin with. Once I realize that something is not right, I mentally pull back and reboot. That takes some energy but far less than it would to persist down the wrong path -- or no path at all.

We're all pretty good problem solvers. That doesn't mean that we're always solving the right problems.

-jr

Friday, October 3, 2008

Warren Buffett On The Economy

Buffett was interviewed on the Charlie Rose show for just under an hour on Wednesday evening:

Tuesday, September 30, 2008

Why Smart People Fail To Make Money Online

Finally moved (mostly) over to the new apartment. We stayed here last night for the first time. Still a bit more to pack up from the old place. Thanks to my mom and my brother for helping us get the bulk of stuff moved (especially our Cal King bed -- up to the third floor master bedroom - doh!).

Ran across a blog post from Brandon Uttley of Web Business Freedom this morning which fits into a lot of my current thinking.... I encourage you to poke through it:

Why is it that so many smart people, who are savvy enough to use a computer every day and chock full of expertise, are blind to opportunities to attract more business through the web?

...more...

Wednesday, September 10, 2008

Audit Boy (or Girl), I Love/Hate You

I have a love/hate relationship with audits.

Let's talk about them in the IT realm. I think they have the potential to do some real good. And, in certain cases, they have. Just how much is very difficult to quantify with any degree of confidence.

We could look for trend changes, for a variety of problems targeted by audits but.... it's not easy to prove a cause and effect relationship. No doubt marketers of auditing and related consulting services can come up with some statistics but I don't buy it.

For example, even without audits, it's reasonable to expect a variety of problems to plateau as adoption cycles peak. The acceptance and understanding of particular problems -- and their solutions -- improves as time passes. Heck, sometimes having one really widely publicized (and costly) hit on another organization can be more effective than an audit at getting problems fixed (at least in the short-term). There are loads of other possible factors, including macro & micro-economic.

So, for the moment, I'll go with that I do know about the impact of audits -- from actual observation.

Audits certainly aren't "fun" so why do we care about all this? Well, because if we're going to have to go through the process anyway -- and probably repeatedly -- why not try to get as much benefit as possible out of it? Think of it as trying to get the most bang for your buck...even if you were forced to spend the buck. :-)

Many audits I've seen suffer from some variation of the following flaws (I'll discuss the positives momentarily):

  • They encourage organizations to overlook the forest for the trees. Management is happy because the auditor left without an adverse opinion. IT is happy because people are off their back. Life goes on and, especially in environments where firefighting is the norm, things get forgotten that weren't truly covered in the audit. For example: should we be doing anything with the data from that brand spanking new intrusion prevention system purchased, initially, for the audit? (sometimes it's left there until the next audit anniversary comes around when they get to point it out to the auditor with a look of relief...and hope the auditor doesn't want to strike up any small talk about "what they think of it" thus far).
  • They increase the burden on the IT department. While a super on the ball IT department without any extra resources might be hurt by this, for most others this may be a wash since it'll catch a few things they might have missed and help them justify some much needed resources.
  • They create a false sense of security for management, staff, users, and customers (kind of like airport security inspections)
  • Audits are not created equal and they are difficult to compare quantitatively. Most of the intended beneficiaries (end-users, customers, clients) of audits are certainly not equipped to be able to tell any two audits apart or evaluate the actual versus perceived merits of a given audit.. Hacker Safe(tm) anyone?
  • The more useful audits tend to be the most pain-in-the-ass. Thus no one wants to undertake them (except the auditor who is likely charging significant fees). Ironically the least useful fall into BOTH camps: some are ridiculously painless (and useless) on a technical basis while others are a severe pain-in-the-ass with minimal, if any, benefit.
  • Most widely used (and publicized) standardized audits are either too rigid or too vague. It's tough to get both widespread adoption of a standard spec (e.g. PCI) that is both highly specific and relevant. While there are some best practices, there are no two environments that are exactly the same. And, hell, who is to say that the owner's decision to simply buy really good liability insurance is imprudent?
  • Human nature gets the better of us. No one likes being told what to do and explaining our (sometimes sloppy and other times simply pragmatic) past decisions is rarely fun. An adversarial feeling and (at least a bit of) resentment is not uncommon. This leads to sliding things under the rug. Often the IT folks already know the scary areas. Too bad there isn't a good way for them to disclose all that information..... for the constructive benefit of the organization...
On the positive side:
  • Audits have provided fuel to IT managers and staffers in justifying investments in infrastructure enhancements. In competent hands, and as long as nobody goes overboard, this is good stuff.
  • They occasionally catch stuff missed even by the most competent.
  • Seriously negligent organizations are (more likely to be) caught sooner (or at least their cost of hiding is raised enough that it becomes more cost effective for them to simply get up to par rather than fight).
  • Audits get management attention. Very productive discussions about security, risk, and policy management often come out of this.
Which of these same situations may have occurred in your own organization?

By starting some discussions within your organization -- not just within the IT department, but also within the executive suite, and perhaps in consultation with a constructive representative on the legal side -- resources consumed by the audit process can made more effective.

While no on likes to spend time & money they didn't chose to, at least you still have control over the specifics of how it is spent and what the long-term benefits can be to the organization. It's got to be a better result than simply passing the latest audit.

(As an aside, an idea I've been kicking around with some of my clients is aligning the marketing folks with the IT department to publicize positive audit results and to justify more extensive investments, that still make sense in a business sense, beyond simply what the audit minimums are. Thus creating a potential competitive advantage out of the whole thing. An idea to kick around in your own organization perhaps).

-jr

Friday, September 5, 2008

Common Sense Easy To Forget

Common sense and a sprinkle of self-confidence is the best way to succeed in a new business, project, cause, or other change in our lives. It has far less to do with prior experience, schooling, etc. than many think.

A great way to insure we stick with the common sense approach is to ignore what the industry norms are. That doesn't mean defy them just to be defiant. But it does mean defy them when we understand why we want to (put the other way: when we understand that the norm doesn't actually make any sense in and of itself -- at least for our goals).

Most of us have common sense, but it's easy to miss the forest for the trees when we're caught up in the middle of an industry or a particular problem, emotionally reacting, discussing a situation within a group setting, letting the client's past approach to a situation guide our approach, or unsure of ourselves.

Seek out ways to detect when you may be falling into this trap. Then experiment with ways to knock yourself out of it when it happens. Since it's a re-occurring problem, well, you'll have plenty of opportunities to test and refine your detection methods and remedies.

-jr